TT-NEWS Tischtennis Forum

Zusätzliche Einstellungen
Verschiedene Einstellungen Links automatisch umwandeln

27.11.2005 15:53

Josip

AW: Re: back to 21

are there still players who want back the 21-rule?

i love the 11-rule, it tooks a litte bit time at the beginning, but now i like it!

26.12.2003 23:35

Nosti49

Re: back to 21

First I had some problems with the deduction to 11 points/set.
But already after 2 month there was no problem anymore and later I found that I had more chances to win against someone being generally better than me, especially due to the fact that a "series", which you perhaps have during 5-6 points NOW influences dramatically the whole set.

Also players being not as good as me had now more chances to win one or two sets. That makes the whole game more interesting, I think.

Ciao
Norbert

08.07.2003 13:26

JanMove

In my opinion, the best solution would have been to play a game up to 13 points with a change of service after 3 points. Then the total number of points for a best of 5 and 7 match, respectively, would be approximately the same as it was before. Moreover, there would be a better flow in the match, particularly, in the doubles. Additionally, the four players of a double would be equally treated, as it is not the case if one plays up to 11.
If I have the choice between 11 and 21, I would prefer 21!!

JanMove

26.06.2003 17:42

Roesslerc

I didn´t play to 21, but 11 is good, isn´t it?

21.06.2003 17:35

sriver_fx

Re: back to 21

Zitat:

Original geschrieben von zhang
what is your opinion? back to 21 or is 11 good?
while thinking that 11-up is more exciting, i think that some aspects of the new format should be looked into...

if the ITTF approx. halves the number of points per games (from 21 to 11), shouldn't they also double the number of games, to maintain equilibrium??? it will also ensure that upset wins have to be earned, across the board (at every level of the game)...

in a very close game... as close as close can be... (e.g. winner of a set wins 21-19, or now 11-9)

---------------------
21-up avg. 40 points per game x 5 sets = 200 points

11-up avg. 20 points per game x 9 sets = 180 points
11-up avg. 20 points per game x 7 sets = 140 points [the current case]
---------------------

i think the above proves that the ITTF should pay some attention to increasing the number of games per match!!!

in fact, i see no excuse for not doing so...
the ITTF can't say players will be more tired - as earlier they used to play even more points! for the same reason, they cannot say that matches will take longer... in fact, the 9 game format will only ensure a fairer result!

29.05.2003 23:33

Amok "Orginal"

21 ..... 4 ever!!!!!!

*lol* i wanna go back to 21 !!! so you can "play" a little bit more *g* and there is no need to concentrate all the time ... thats more relaxed

23.05.2003 10:59

vladim (poland)

it will be 11, no way back to 21

20.05.2003 18:20

pelirroja

At first I didn't like the sets of 11 points at all, but now I prefer the short sets because they're much more interesting!

19.05.2003 23:15

Joachim Voigt

yes, chines fed wants to go back to 21. I like to play to 11 and it would be a desaster in public to change back to 21.

19.05.2003 23:09

Morten (from Norway)

I want to play sets ending at 11, but I think that the chinese federation want returning to 21.

Dieses Thema enthält mehr als 10 Antworten. Klicken Sie hier, um das ganze Thema zu lesen.

Forumregeln
Es ist Ihnen erlaubt, neue Themen zu verfassen. Es ist Ihnen erlaubt, auf Beiträge zu antworten. Es ist Ihnen nicht erlaubt, Anhänge hochzuladen. Es ist Ihnen nicht erlaubt, Ihre Beiträge zu bearbeiten. BB-Code ist an. Smileys sind an. [IMG] Code ist an. HTML-Code ist aus. Foren-Regeln